Monday, 13 January 2014

Why are young people leaving the church?

Yesterday I was asked why I thought young people are leaving the church, so I said I'd have a think about it and write something down. Here it is.

I think if you express the question differently, as 'why are the unsaved offspring of Christian parents leaving the Church?' the answer sort of drops out of its own accord. The reason they leave the church is because there's nothing there of interest for them, because not being a Christian they don't find any fellowship with Christians and have no love for Christians.

People sometimes speak of the children of Christian parents losing their faith, but rather I suspect that they were never Christians in the first place – it was only a veneer they put on as children are wont to do in front of their parents, and of course by their mid-twenties there is really no need to pretend any more so their true nature shows. A profession of faith is by no means a sure sign of salvation, and I think it's good to be cautious about a child's (or anyone's) profession of faith until it's consistently shown fruit. In the parable of the sower, three types of seed made a start but only one kind bore fruit.

Some churches tend to combat tendency of unsaved young people leaving by making their church meetings desirable places for unsaved young people to be. In these churches you find excitement and opportunities to become part of the 'in-crowd', because young adults still love to be part of an in-crowd.

Ironically this means they they are becoming another version of the often-criticised 'church as a social club' – though this one is for young adults, not old adults. I wonder where they will be in fifty years?

I visited a local church recently where, after a strikingly vacuous sermon, the pastor explained that, in keeping with 'Sticky Church', a church growth book he had recently read, he was going to put a lot more emphasis on homegroups in future so that new people 'stick around' more and the church can grow. I thought that actually, Christians don't need to be stuck down to a church – they need to be fed. They'll stick around of their own accord. I didn't stay there.

Anyway the real question to ask is not why unsaved young people are leaving the church. I'd rather ask, 'Why are the church-attending children of professing Christian parents not repenting of their sin and believing in Jesus Christ?'

The responsibility for children's training in godliness is with parents, especially fathers: Fathers, do not provoke your children to anger, but bring them up in the discipline and instruction of the Lord. (Eph 6:4)

Big commands come in small sentences. This one will occupy a man's best endeavours for twenty or more years. For a father just to 'be around' his children is not enough: it's taken for granted that he'll be around. And during that time he will be bringing his children up, one way or another. Even plants need the right care to grow well, and the successful growth of plants has become a science – how much more does the upbringing of children need to be thought about, planned, and executed with great care and diligence?

Training children is not something for just anyone to do, and although Sunday school teachers may well provide a useful service (I speak as someone who has Christian teaching experience myself) it is simply not possible for Sunday school to provide some sort of 'spiritual recharge' for children that will see them through the week. They don't need to be seen through the week, they need a diligent, consistent, ready-in-season-and-out-of-season, whole-life upbringing that will train them in godliness. And it is the father's responsibility, with his wife being the main help in that work. When parents give the responsibility for upbringing over to the church – and worse, the State – it just doesn't work. The whole of a child's upbringing is spiritual, it needs to be intentional, and it needs to be overseen and carried out by the parents.

Unfortunately the current crop of Christian parents don't seem to have been taught that they must train their children in the ways of the Lord. Many do not believe that it's their place to discipline and train their children, and so their children grow up in an environment that is nominally Christian but is little different to that of their non-Christian peers. Christian children effectively receive a non-Christian upbringing, except for perhaps the attempts of the Sunday school teacher to Christianize them.

If we really do accept that unsaved people are inherently wicked – as the Bible teaches – then we should also accept that it is madness to turn our children over to them to be raised as they see fit. It is also madness to adopt theories of child-rearing that were devised in the minds of wicked men, in preference to those taught in the Bible.

Anyway, to close. The subject of growing cress could fill a book, so of course these few paragraphs are not a complete manual or doctrinal position on how to make sure your children end up as Christians. It needs serious thought, and especially it needs Christians to consider the what the Bible says and to do their best to action it. "Thy word is a lamp unto my feet and a light unto my path."